Now streaming: Pixar’s ‘Lightyear’ is an emotional, mind-bending space odyssey
Photo: ©Disney
ORLANDO - Editor's note: This review originally ran on June 17, 2022 as "Lightyear" hit theaters. It has been republished in light of the film's premiere on Disney+.
"Lightyear," the latest film from the animation powerhouses at Pixar, must have seemed like a sure thing to Disney executives. It’s got Chris Evans, still riding high off his uber-buzzy (no pun intended) success in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It’s a prequel of sorts to a beloved Pixar title, something the studio has proven can work thanks to 2013’s well-received "Monsters University." And the movie in question isn’t a Pixar title, it’s the Pixar title: "Toy Story," a landmark event for the studio and the world of animation.
That confidence seems to have been warranted. "Lightyear" isn’t quite Pixar at its most emotionally potent, and the pacing veers a little too close to the big-budget action formula at times, but there’s enough emotional potency and clever plotting to make "Lightyear" a solid addition to Pixar’s ever-growing roster of family flicks.
RELATED: Movie review: ‘DC League of Super-Pets’ has delightful Saturday morning cartoon vibes
About "Lightyear": To the origin story — and beyond
Starring Evans as the titular space ranger, "Lightyear" is (as the film’s opening text tells us) meant to be the film that Andy, the resident toy-owner of "Toy Story," saw before the events of the first film – in other words, the movie that inspired him to ask his parents for a Buzz Lightyear toy for his birthday. This Buzz is a driven, lone-wolf space ranger whose world is thrown into turmoil after he accidentally crashes a Star Command ship, stranding himself on a hostile alien planet. When he comes to the tragic realization that every attempt to get back to light-speed results in a four-year time jump, Buzz finds himself aligning with an unlikely group of heroes (including the granddaughter of his best friend) to crack the secret to hyper-speed, destroy the terrifying Zurg ship and find a way to return home once and for all.
Photo: ©Disney
To the film’s credit, creating a film that Andy would’ve seen in the ‘90s allows "Lightyear" to dodge any confusing questions about the "Toy Story" timeline, toy sentience and other messy issues that would’ve arisen had screenwriters Jason Headley and Angus MacLane attempted to set "Lightyear" in the "Toy Story" world. (MacLane is also the film’s director.) Instead, by making "Lightyear" its own film, Headley and MacLane give themselves the creative freedom to craft a compelling narrative that doesn’t need to tie into the canon. The result is a surprisingly complicated time-travel story that explores grief, self-love and the importance of knowing when to ask for help.
WATCH FREE ON TUBI: The iconic time loop of "Groundhog Day"
See "Lightyear" for: A great Chris Evans performance
Evans makes a passable attempt at mimicking the distinctive cadence Tim Allen gave the toy Buzz in the "Toy Story" trilogy, but the depth and emotionality Evans brings to the character more than make up for any shortcomings in the imitation department. Allen’s Buzz is the comic relief while Tom Hanks’ Woody plays the role of the straight man, but surprisingly, "Lightyear" and Evans take Buzz quite seriously as a protagonist — more often than not, he’s the stick-in-the-mud straight man, the voice of reason in a room full of chaos.
There’s real emotional maturity to the character arc "Lightyear" develops for Buzz; once again, Pixar calls on its uncanny ability to wring tears from an audience regardless of the subject matter. Buzz, a military man through and through who lives by the mantra of "finishing the mission," spends a large chunk of the film stricken with guilt over stranding the crew of the Star Command vessel. It’s surprisingly tragic, especially given how quickly it’s addressed in the film, and the emotional impact of these early scenes resonates well past the first act.
Credit: Disney/Pixar
WATCH FREE ON TUBI: Chris Evans lends his voice to the 2007 "TMNT" movie — get the app
Without question, Buzz serves as the film’s emotional anchor, and when the (now obligatory) surprise villain reveal comes around, it’s Buzz’s stake in the situation that helps the reveal land (even if some of the plot mechanics behind it feel a little convoluted). Nearly every truly wonderful moment of "Lightyear" results from the film’s investment in Buzz as a character and the emotional burden he carries. It’s not the most kid-friendly of character arcs, but it’s certainly a compelling approach.
The film’s supporting cast, however, isn’t anywhere near as well fleshed-out or impactful — perhaps that was unavoidable, given the amount of screentime devoted to Buzz. Keke Palmer stars as Izzy, the granddaughter of Buzz’s best friend Alisha Hawthorne (Uzo Aduba), and though she’s confident and self-assured, she struggles with a crippling fear of space — an inconvenient affliction for an aspiring space ranger. Izzy makes a serviceable ingenue to the older, darker Buzz, but her subplot feels underbaked.
Taika Waititi and Dale Soules round out the rag-tag bunch as Mo and Darby, a cowardly, accident-prone trainee and an aging ex-con respectively, who act as the film’s comic relief. But their combined presence comes nowhere close to eliciting the laughs that robot cat Sox nabs (courtesy of clever writing and a scene-stealing vocal performance from Peter Sohn). It’s difficult to shake the feeling that the absence of Mo and Darby would’ve allowed for a much more effective interpersonal connection between Buzz and Izzy.
Still, despite some flat side characters and a by-the-numbers plot structure/villain twist, there’s enough ingenuity and emotional gravitas in "Lightyear" to make for a compelling, if predictable, trip to the stars.
Grade: B-
About the writer: Lauren Coates is a Chicago-based film critic and entertainment writer with a passion for queer and female-led media and an everlasting love for all things sci-fi. You can find her on twitter @laurenjcoates.
Make it a double feature with "The Boxtrolls," streaming free on Tubi
The Boxtrolls (2014): At one point in "The Boxtrolls," a film from the stop-motion animation studio Laika, 10-year-old Winnie (voiced by Elle Fanning) asks her new acquittance Eggs (Isaac Hempstead Wright) about his friends, the Boxtrolls. Legend has it that these sewer-dwelling trolls are quite fearsome. In reality, they wear cardboard boxes as clothes, steal bits of scrap metal in the night and are actually quite friendly, even merry. But Winnie doesn’t know that yet, and her hopes are high. "Did they eat your family, and did they let you watch?" she asks eagerly. Eggs expresses confusion, and she hastily corrects herself: "I mean, make you watch." She attempts to return her mask of ladylike propriety, but it's clear where her obsessions lie. Winnie’s fascination with the macabre — she’s heard about rivers of blood, and piles of bones from all the babies the Boxtrolls are said to eat — becomes both a funny running gag and a canny bit of characterization in this refreshing, underrated film. Read the rest of film critic Jesse Hassenger's retrospective. Rated PG. 96 minutes. Dir: Graham Annable and Anthony Stacchi. Also featuring Ben Kingsley, Jared Harris, Nick Frost, Richard Ayoade, Steve Blum, Dee Bradley Baker, Max Mitchell, Tracy Morgan, Nika Futterman, Toni Collette, Simon Pegg.
"The Boxtrolls" is streaming for free on Tubi — get the app
How to watch Pixar’s "Lightyear"
"Lightyear" is now streaming on Disney+ and is still playing in select theaters.
About Tubi: Tubi has more than 40,000 movies and television series from over 250 content partners, including every major studio, in addition to the largest offering of free live local and national news channels in streaming. The platform gives fans of entertainment, news and sports an easy way to discover new content that is available completely free.
Tubi is available on Android and iOS mobile devices, Amazon Echo Show, Google Nest Hub Max, Comcast Xfinity X1, Cox Contour, and on OTT devices such as Amazon Fire TV, Vizio TVs, Sony TVs, Samsung TVs, Roku, Apple TV, Chromecast, Android TV, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X | S, and soon on Hisense TVs globally. Consumers can also watch Tubi content on the web at http://www.tubi.tv/.
Tubi and this television station are both owned by the FOX Corporation.